Description/Reason:
We can say puq to refer to a child regardless of gender, but no analog exists for parent.
Comment below with feedback and suggestions.
Responses
Comments are closed.
Category: Language User
We can say puq to refer to a child regardless of gender, but no analog exists for parent.
Comment below with feedback and suggestions.
Comments are closed.
Please confirm you want to block this member.
You will no longer be able to:
Please allow a few minutes for this process to complete.
This isn't just qup?
chay' 'etlh DoQ nuch / QongtaHbogh qup 'etlh nIH "How does a coward claim a sword? By taking it from his sleeping father."
I don't get the feeling that qup means parent to the exclusion of other elders. I wouldn't expect a quprIp to be composed only of parents – and then of whose parents?
On further reflection, it actually seems very likely that qup actually means "parent", but generalizes to "elder" much in the same way that when I talk about a puq, I could be talking about a child without meaning for it to be antbody's child in particular. qup being puq backwards just seems like too much of a coincidence. qup'a' also seems to suggest something parental, and not merely "elder"ly, about qup.
It would be nice to have "parent" specifically confirmed as a possible meaning of qup.
>>It would be nice to have "parent" specifically confirmed as a possible meaning of qup.
Reply
Definitely. If an English word isn't canonically listed as a possible translation of the Klingon term, and it isn't a simple synonym (like "bucket" and "pail" or "shy" and "diffident") either, there's always some doubt as to whether this is really the way Klingons would say it.