ghItlhpu' Qov, jatlh:
> Now does anyone want to suggest which letter frequencies we
diminish in order to
> bring the qaghwI' frequency up close to the 'at frequency?
Especially considering that building upon words already on the board
is a big part of Scrabble, and a couple of extra qaghwI'mey opens up
opportunities for that considering how many affixes contain it.
I know that Noah has put together a frequency distribution, which is
pretty good, but I was halfway through my own and so I'll post it as
well. It's based on four main texts in substantially different
genres: ghIlghameS, the existing portion of mIl'oD veDDIr SuvwI',
nuq bop bom, and the Tao Te Ching. nuq bop bom is by far the largest
(350431 characters, vs. 122250 for mIl'oD veDDIr SuvwI', 34901 for
ghIlghameS, and 22589 for the Tao), so in order to take this into
account I multiplied the other three texts' results up so that the
populations from each text matched in size. I'm happy to send on the
Excel file with the stats in it so that the numbers can be checked.
0 points: chIm (2)
1 point: 'at (10), qaghwI' (10), 'It (8), 'et (8), 'ot (6), 'ut (6), Hay (5)
2 points: jay (5), may (5), Day (4), vay (4)
3 points: lay (3), ghay (2), bay (2), chay (2), Say (2), qay (2), nay (2)
4 points: tay (2), pay (2)
5 points: yay (2), way (2)
6 points: Qay (1), ray (1)
8 points: tlhay (1)
10 points: ngay (1)
As in English, the total is 100 tiles, and a sum point total of 200 points.
I've reduced the point value on tlhay, because as Qov points out,
it's somewhat overvalued at ten points: in the all-texts percentage,
ngay is by far the rarest, having a frequency of 0.86% (compared to
tlhay, which has 1.49%, only just behind ray). The current standard
distribution has two raymey and for the potential for playing -rgh
codas it'd be nice to keep two, but the frequency really doesn't
justify it: it's ranked 24th of 26 in the all-texts percentage. The
duplication of yay and way is because of the existence of -y/-y' and
-w/-w' codas. Noah, in your distribution I would argue that of the
two, it should be yay, not way, that has two tiles: way can't appear
in the syllable coda for 40% of potential syllable shapes.
Unfortunately there's also the need for a relatively high proportion
of vowels so that playing verb prefixes won't deplete the
vowel-consonant ratio too much, so the total of vowels is 38 of the
98 letter tiles. (The current distribution has 42 vowels.)
QeS
_______________________________________________
Tlhingan-hol mailing list
[email protected]
http://stodi.digitalkingdom.org/mailman/listinfo/tlhingan-hol