tlhIngan-Hol Archive: Wed Oct 28 15:51:46 2009
[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next]
RE: intuition and grammar (was Re: Ditransitive reflexives)
eric mead (firstname.lastname@example.org)
I share Andre's sentiment, and I was wondering if anyone has ever done a full-blown linguistic analysis of the more fluent speakers of Klingon??
At some point, I imagine it will be relevant to 'analyze' the language as it has come to be used. Anyone tried?
> Date: Wed, 28 Oct 2009 18:55:41 +0100
> Subject: Re: intuition and grammar (was Re: Ditransitive reflexives)
> From: email@example.com
> To: firstname.lastname@example.org
> 2009/10/28 <email@example.com>
> > If speakers are allowed to add their own grammar into the language,
> > doesn't that defeat the purpose of speaking the native language of the
> > Klingons? I don't know if I should be saying anything considering my n00b
> > status but I just couldn't help but seeing that. I know that in any other
> > language grammar is set in stone and never changed.
> > Just my two cents
> Quite the contrary actually. No grammar is really "set in stone" (in the
> sense of 'may not change over time'). Grammar (as well as the lexicon and
> the semantics) in natural languages changes over time, due to speakers
> introducing new habits, stopping using certain forms or making "mistakes",
> which spread and get grammaticalized sometimes. Some of these changes we can
> notice ourselves.
> The only languages with a grammar "set in stone" that I could think of,
> would be constructed ones. Not Klingon, as Okrand adds stuff to it (not much
> and not too often, but still once in a while). Not Esperanto, as it has
> changed a little since its invention too... but those two languages'
> grammars get close to be "set in stone".
> So in Klingon, speakers (with the exception of Marc Okrand) are not allowed
> to change the grammar or to introduce new words, although there's no one
> really to punish them. ;)
> Prescriptive grammars in natural languages such as English or German are
> merely a snapshot of the grammar currently used by the majority of the
> people... and sometimes (at least for the German Duden grammar) it's partly
> obsolete and should be updated to reflect the modern grammar of the
> Just my two (Euro-)cents. :)
> - André
Windows 7: Simplify your PC. Learn more.