tlhIngan-Hol Archive: Tue Jan 29 07:09:42 2002
[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next]
> From: firstname.lastname@example.org
> I have read Lawrence's article "Some Comments on
> Orthography" on the KLI site as well as what
> little Mark wrote concerning pIqaD in TDK.
> A direct quote from TDK, pg 11:
> "There is a native writing system for Klingon
> (called pIqaD) which seems to be well suited to
> the various dialects" More follows, but AFAIAC
> this one comment by Okrand made pIqaD official in
> MY mind.
The thing is I suppose, The word pIqaD is canon so
we know that Klingons have a writing system but not
what it is.. We have all seen the symbolism used
by the other MO on the show but as has been said
before this means nothing and represents no more
than a visual.. Okuda stated in HolQeD 1:1 that in
his mind Klingon i.e. his pIqaD is read from the
centre outwards but he just does what he feels will
look good (I haven't got the issue with me so please
feel free to read it and correct me).
There is also an article in that HolQeD issue re: the
origins of the KLI pIqaD font from an allegedly
leaked document and the KLI used that..
At the end of the day the KLI's pIqaD is as readable
to a Klingon as is the Romanised representation used
I think I can feel fairly safe to say that:
1) pIqaD is an Canon word
2) The pIqaD characters/symbols are official symbols
3) KLIpIqadmey font is an unofficial use of these symbols
If the KLI had not taken this on board we would
probably have been faced with all and sundry creating
their own variation (all would probably have been as
legitimate as the next)..
> The key word being 'is'. Not 'might be'
> or 'could be' or 'may be'. What follows in that
> page 11 paragraph seems to open doors for more
> 'discoveries' about the Klingon writing system.
> I used pIqaD to write the words tlhIngan Hol on
> the cover of a study book I made for myself.
> So maybe if someone did write a note to a Klingon
> using pIqaD he wouldn't be able to read it....
Anyone taking that argument against the use of
KLIpIqaDmey in my mind is on very thin ice... They
would fall foul of the whole language in whatever
format we have so far seen it.. In theory the Only
writing a Klingon would be able to read would be
the pattern of symbols shown on the show by Mike
Okuda.. We don't know what they mean but officially
speaking they do represent how a Klingon would see
them... We don't know how to write Klingon so even
the familiar words in TKD etc would mean nothing
to any Klingon except Maltz.
> I would.
Thanks to the KLI's foresight we have a standard
that we can play with and can be translated by any
terran learns that standard or can convert fonts
and read it that way.
Long live KLI's pIqaD!!! }};-)
> Cat >^..^<