tlhIngan-Hol Archive: Sat Dec 01 19:07:19 2007
[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next]
Re: Basic grammar question
Doq wrote:
> maleng qorDu'wIj.
>
> Does it work? It does seem very strange and we have no canon to back
> it up as normal. Why does it seem strange?
It seems strange because it violates the known rules given in TKD.
> If we didn't have this parallel English construction, there would not
> have been anything to prepare us for {tajwIj qanob}. Since we do have
> the construction in English, the Klingon is easy to understand.
Let's be clear about this. Okrand came up with the "prefix trick" on a
message board, not in a book, which means it almost certainly wasn't a
planned feature. I'll tell you — without evidence — what it was: his
attention was called to a number of examples which violate the rules in
TKD in a way that English speakers would find natural because of rules
of English, so he backfit an explanation.
I was the one who coined the name "prefix trick," you know, and I did so
sarcastically.
> Meanwhile, English doesn't allow us to say "My family travel," and
> know that I'm counting myself as part of my family. Someone would
> want to correct me and say, "My family travels." Make it third
> person, not first.
Some dialects of English might allow "My family travel." I pointed out
earlier that British English, for example, often treats singular nouns
that refer to groups as if they were plural.
> Do we know that doesn't happen in Klingon? No. Do we know it does
> happen in Klingon? No.
But we DO know that it apparently violates rules set out in TKD. Given
that at least, I'd stick to the book.
SuStel
Stardate 7918.2